Each FromSoftware SoulsBorne DLC Ranked

FromSoftware has lastly introduced the primary DLC expansion for Elden Ring, Shadow of the Erdtree.

Whereas we solely know that the brand new growth is formally being developed, FromSoftware has a historical past of releasing substantial expansions which might be wealthy with each new areas and managers in addition to new story content material. They’re usually basically mini sequels to the bottom recreation that normally end the sport’s story and conceal the true ending.

With this in thoughts, we ranked all of the previous FromSoftware DLC for Darkish Souls and Bloodborne and revisited the expansions from a studio that has arguably carried out DLC higher than anybody else. Test under for our ranked checklist of FromSoftware DLC.

Spoilers for Darkish Souls and Bloodborne DLC under.

7-6.)  Darkish Souls 2: Crown of the Previous Iron King and Darkish Souls 2: Crown of the Sunken King

As a Darkish Souls 2 apologist, my principal criticism with the Darkish Souls sequel comes right down to steadiness points. Whereas Darkish Souls 2 would find yourself pioneering among the open-world parts of the sport that we’ll see in a while in Elden Ring (Darkish Souls 2 co-director Yui Tanimura will go on to co-direct Elden Ring alongside Hidetaka Miyazaki), Darkish Souls 2 additionally felt bewilderingly troublesome in a means that was neither enjoyable nor significantly rewarding. 

The DLC for Darkish Souls 2 suffers from the identical drawback, and actually provides among the most irritating areas in the whole Darkish Souls sequence, which might be as tedious as they’re narratively fascinating. Whether or not it’s Shulva, an underground metropolis constructed to worship a toxic dragon, but additionally options extremely annoying platforming and hidden switches. To Brume Tower, an attractive fortress guarded by a number of gameplay-modifying enemies referred to as Ashen Idols.

Whereas I personally most well-liked the darker aesthetics of Sunken King, which takes place in a sequence of Mesoamerican-inspired pyramids in a sprawling underground kingdom, each DLC appear to take essentially the most pleasure in seeing simply how aggravating a Souls space could be. 

Together with the Crown of the Ivory King, Crown of the Sunken King and Crown of the Old Iron King make up the Misplaced Crown Trilogy for Darkish Souls 2, and the primary two DLC are positioned on the backside of the rankings for a similar motive as why Darkish Souls 2 is commonly remembered much less fondly than the opposite two video games within the trilogy. 

5.) Darkish Souls 3: Ashes of Ariandel

The primary of two Darkish Souls 3 DLC, Ashes of Ariandel revisits the idea of painted worlds first launched in Darkish Souls 1. 

Whereas The Ringed Metropolis units the stage for the ultimate act of the Darkish Souls trilogy, the preliminary DLC takes place in a  comparatively small and sparse world. The Snowfield space is solely a big open discipline populated by robust warrior enemies, and whereas it’s beautiful, feels largely optionally available, Although does characteristic an important twist on a fan-favorite boss struggle from Darkish Souls 1.

The true coronary heart of the DLC doesn’t seem till you meet Sir Vilhelm and Sister Friede on the Cathedral. FromSoftware appears to make up for the DLC’s lack of enemy selection by placing an thrilling, three-phase boss battle inside the chapel partitions. The one different space is a PvP enviornment behind a really cool boss struggle, set in an space that just about seems like an homage to the ultimate struggle in Metallic Gear Strong 3.

One notice, when gamers lastly face Sir Vilhelm, he delivers a blistering meta critique on the participant accusing the participant of needing to “unearth each secret” even when it finally ends up destroying the world. The concept the inhabitants of the Darkish Souls world is aware of that progressing via the sport means solely sure doom for each the world and its residents seems to be the principle theme of each Darkish Souls 3 DLC, and an exquisite little bit of meta storytelling.

4.) Darkish Souls 2: Crown of the Ivory King

The ultimate DLC within the Darkish Souls 2 DLC trilogy stands other than the earlier two by way of each what it provides to the Darkish Souls story and having a tremendous ultimate boss struggle.

Whereas the Sunken King and Previous Iron King DLC employed new mechanics to primarily up the issue, the Ivory King DLC seems like a fully-fleshed location because of the frozen kingdom of Eleum Loyce.

From the second you step foot into Eleum Loyce, each problem retaining you from progressing is tied to the tragic story of Alsanna and the Burnt Ivory King. Its principal gameplay twist, which entails rescuing a number of imprisoned knights of Eleum Loyce, builds in direction of one of the crucial distinctive boss fights within the sequence which takes the idea of preventing a number of bosses directly and flips it on its head in order that the participant employs a small military to tackle the principle enemy. 

Whereas they rank backside of our checklist, the Misplaced Crown Trilogy was nonetheless an formidable sequence of DLC that added a correct narrative thread that bridges the occasions between Darkish Souls 1 and a couple of. Manus, the principle boss of the primary Darkish Souls DLC, casts a big shadow over the occasions of Darkish Souls 2 and its expansions. Whereas the disjointed nature of Darkish Souls 2 finally backfires, the concept the Darkish Souls universe is comprised of numerous kingdoms and cultures, throughout so many various eras and time might be Darkish Souls 2’s biggest contribution to the sequence as an entire.

3.) Darkish Souls 3: The Ringed Metropolis

Darkish Souls 3 is on a mission to place an finish to the occasions that began within the first recreation. The second DLC, The Ringed City is supposed to function the penultimate chapter of the Darkish Souls trilogy, with the participant venturing into the Ringed Metropolis, the dominion of the Pygmy Lords first revealed in Darkish Souls 1.

The Ringed Metropolis ranks up there with among the finest cities launched within the Souls sequence. The partitions of the dominion could be seen caving in on themselves as if being sucked right into a vortex, presumably a reference to Junji Ito’s tragic city in Uzumaki. 

The enemies that roam the town are each dynamic to struggle towards and hanging of their design, such because the angels of dying actually guarding the skies and raining down hellfire, or the Judicators who summon the spirits of armies to defend the town. Then, when the participant lastly travels deeper into its partitions and previous time and house itself, they’ll face off towards among the finest sword-to-sword enemies within the recreation that’s each a remix of one in every of Darkish Souls’ finest DLC bosses, Artorias of the Abyss.

The true gems hidden in The Ringed Metropolis DLC are the way it converges the longstanding storylines of the Darkish Souls sequence. There’re factions that cling to the cult of Gwyn, Lord of Cinder, and like within the Ashes of Ariandel, The Ringed Metropolis is dwelling to one of many recreation’s nice NPCs who will put the participant on trial for all their ambitions. As a bookend to the sequence, The Ringed Metropolis is a triumph and as narratively easy as you may get within the Darkish Souls sequence.

2.) Darkish Souls: Artorias of the Abyss

The primary DLC launched within the Souls sequence, Artorias of the Abyss would introduce the template for all Souls DLC. When FromSoftware built-in the DLC content material immediately into the bottom recreation, including a hidden portal that gamers want to seek out to be able to even entry the DLC, it opened up a world of prospects for the Souls franchise. Out of the blue every new Darkish Souls recreation was hiding a pathway to some potential new space and questlines that will be launched later by way of an growth DLC.

The whole lot else, like a troublesome doorkeeper boss, devoted PvP space, would go on to turn into FromSoftware staples. And naturally among the finest (and most tragic) boss fights in the whole sequence is tucked away within the growth. Crucially, the brand new space of Oolacile additionally launched Manus, Father of the Abyss, whose affect would lengthen via the sequence all the way in which to Darkish Souls 3.

With Artorias of the Abyss, FromSoftware confirmed that it wasn’t simply releasing DLC to increase the shelf lifetime of its video games. The DLC expansions in Darkish Souls are transformative, ending essential storylines whereas additionally flexing the studio’s world-building muscle tissue. The boss fights are additionally nearly all the time among the finest within the sequence or on the very least essentially the most troublesome.

1.) Bloodborne: The Previous Hunters

Within the Cathedral Ward, previous the gravestones, an eldritch abomination will transport you to The Hunter’s Nightmare, an epitome of FromSoftware’s formidable achievement that’s Bloodborne.

The Old Hunters DLC is an ideal, three-part play that takes the Hunter via a real, Lovecraftian nightmare that turns into extra sinister the deeper gamers go. The Hunter’s Nightmare begins as if it had been simply one other new Ward to discover. However as soon as gamers get previous Ludwig, they’ll discover Bloodborne’s darkest secrets and techniques hidden away within the Previous Hunters DLC.

The Astral Tower, a analysis facility used for human experimentation, is likely one of the most annoying sources of lore FromSoftware has ever created, culminating in a boss struggle towards the really unforgettable Woman Maria. A duel-style boss that FromSoftware really loves so as to add to its DLC expansions.

As soon as Hunters get previous her, FromSoftware places to relaxation any query that it’s a Lovecraftian horror recreation by immediately adapting Lovecraft’s ‘The Shadow over Innsmouth.’ The fishing village from Lovecraft’s well-known novella is recreated right here. Wading via the oppressive fog and rain, the mazelike village, with the terrifying moon hanging low, too low, overhead, the Fishing Hamlet is a bit nightmare made actual.

The Previous Hunters DLC takes Bloodborne and distills it into its most good kind. Even when solely The Previous Hunters DLC was launched, Bloodborne would nonetheless be thought of a masterpiece, however as a result of — like all FromSoftware DLC — it builds on high of such a strong basis, it completes a recreation that was already firing on all cylinders and reveals that when FromSoftware releases and growth, it’s not optionally available content material however important.

We’ll have to attend and see what FromSoftware does with the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC, however with such a wealthy pedigree of expansions already underneath its belt, the bar is definitely excessive for the primary Elden Ring growth.

Matt T.M. Kim is IGN’s Senior Options Editor. You’ll be able to attain him @lawoftd.